AI Risk Wire

Cases › made things up › LR-2026-0881

Bombay High Court quashes customs Order-in-Original citing non-existent Supreme Court judgments (Quanta Logistics)

Also listed as: AI lawsuits

Who was hit
India
How it was found
Victim
Reported
11 Nov 2026
Severity
Minor
  1. The Commissioner of Customs (Import-I), Mumbai, issued an Order-in-Original penalising the importer Quanta Logistics on August 11, 2026. The task, tools and access are not described; AI use is only the petitioner's argument.
  2. The petitioner argued the authority used AI without independent application of mind, and that two Supreme Court judgments the order cited appeared to be AI hallucinations. The rule crossed is independent application of mind by the adjudicating authority.
  3. The order penalised one importer, Quanta Logistics, and was set aside by consent.
  4. The importer Quanta Logistics noticed the problem, pointing out that the cited Supreme Court judgments could not be traced in legal databases or law reports. The noticer is the affected party.

Source: MediaNama

What was done

The court quashed the order by consent of both parties and directed a fresh order within eight weeks of November 5, 2026. No change to the authority's controls is reported.

Access revoked or keys rotated (Other) · Other stated action (Other)

Risks Made-up output relied on (54 incidents)

No source states: AI company and model, money lost or records, tools it had, company using the AI, sector.

Similar incidents

All cases of this kind ›

Evidence

Sources (1)

  1. Another customs order falls over fake judgments: How Indian courts have responded to AI hallucinations - MEDIANAMA · MediaNama · 2026-11-11
Show every field, with its source and grade

What happened

When it happened
2026-08-11
C one secondary source states it
Earliest source we hold
2026-11-11
D inferred by us from the described behaviour, reason shown
Who caught it
the victim
D inferred by us from the described behaviour, reason shown
What went wrong
made things up
D inferred by us from the described behaviour, reason shown

Impact

Severity
minor
D inferred by us from the described behaviour, reason shown
Why this severity
The order penalised a single importer and was set aside by consent of both parties, with a fresh order directed.
D inferred by us from the described behaviour, reason shown

Context

Country
India
D inferred by us from the described behaviour, reason shown

LR-2026-0881 · version 2 · published 2026-11-11 after automatic checks; not yet checked field by field by a person